This is an automated archive.
The original was posted on /r/amitheasshole by /u/Coln-Gaddafi on 2024-01-08 17:11:20+00:00.
I (M40) have been married to my wife (F38) for 8 years now and together for 11. I get on really well with her brother (M43) who we visited on Saturday of this weekend just gone.
While enjoying catching up, the topic of conversation got onto pets and when my wife and I were going to look at obtaining any as our kids would enjoy the presence of and benefit from bonding and looking after them.
Our property is not the best for dogs or cats, so we were discussing the option of fish (yes, we could get a dog or a cat and there are numerous other pets we could consider, I am simply depicting the conversation flow). This is where things turned amusing, as my wife is a vegetarian and has been since she was four years old, whereas I am not. This has created some "interesting" situations between us historically, but this one at my BIL's was the most entertaining by far!
My wife, quite seriously, stated to me that I will never be able to cook or eat fish in our house ever again if we kept them as pets. Me thinking there would be some ironic/hypocritical logic behind her statement asked her to confirm her reasoning, which she stated very passionately was actually that it would be cruel to do so where our fishy pets could smell the fish being cooked and see me eating them. At that moment, quite taken aback by what my wife had just depicted, my BIL and I caught each other's eye and proceeded to wet ourselves laughing.
Clearly having gone over my wife's head as to why we were in such fits of laughter, my BIL and I started to depict some of the differences between gasses and liquids, as well as the intelligence levels and emotional consciousness of fish... but kept laughing too much, both at my wife's annoyance at us as well as our laughter perpetuating each other.
Numerous references were made between us two for the rest of the afternoon, including designing solutions to catch and condense the steam produced when cooking any fish to then add to the fish tank's water in order to experiment with how our fishy pets would react. We again found this highly amusing (no doubt you would would needed to have been there to have laughed about it as much as we did), but my wife did not.
My wife was, and still is today, very annoyed by us laughing at her expense having realised that her scientific logic was not prevailing at that moment in time. With further silly statements, ideas and GIFS shared within our family WhatsApp group, I am still firmly in the doghouse.
I get that our reactions might have been a little over the top and we may have taken it a bit too far, but considering how funny my BIL and I found it, can I not enjoy myself a little at my wife's expense rather than being subjected to her being clearly disgruntled with my behaviour. I'll obviously drop it following this post, but does Reddit feel that I should apologise? AITA?