This is an automated archive.
The original was posted on /r/amitheasshole by /u/Prestigious-Bat2345 on 2023-12-29 17:36:50+00:00.
Weeks ago, my wife and I made new years plans with my parents. We genuinely like spending time with them, and always have fun and party. My husband doesn't really have family anymore. We wanted to prioritize thanking my folks for a great year, give them a taste of our style of dinner party, and spend quality time together.
We put in a special order for a bunch of ingredients and wines to cook them a really nice meal. We were to host at theirs because there's a lot of space for the whole family and it's great for parties.
My husband asked my sister and her husband what their plans were. They said they had plans but had to cancel because they couldn't find a babysitter. He extended the invitation to their kids to join. Still, their response was "we can't make it, we don't have a sitter."
Yesterday, my mom texts me saying that we are going over to my sister's house to celebrate new years because they feel "alone" and she will bring all the food.
I said that we won't be joining if we're moving locations. I explained all the reasons why (below). She suggested them coming over before and then us going over there after dinner. I said we could, but we would either only go for a bit then leave for a bar to ensure we could enjoy ourselves on NYE. She wasn't happy with that outcome either.
My sister suggested to me that we cook for them at their house or cancel our order for the food and do something else. That really rubbed me the wrong way and I said we would cancel and not join at all.
My reasons:
(1)My sister and her husband live 5 min walking from my parents. There's no reason why they can't join--if even for a bit. (2) Their excuse for getting out of things typically is "we can't get a sitter." Either fix this problem or don't. Don't make it other peoples' problem. (3) When they were invited with their kids, they immediately said no, rather than saying "thanks, we'll think about it" or "we'll try to make it work" or even...."thanks." (4) My sister never made plans with family for new years. Initially, they even asked my parents to babysit for them! (5) All family time revolves around my sister's schedule and her kids 'needs'. Frankly, I am sick of bending to their needs and what feels like an imaginary schedule at every whim. (6) It's not much of a party at their house. We will have to be mindful of sleeping babies and kids. Something fine for any other night, but not NYE. (7) My bother in law constantly shoots passive aggressive and condescending comments to my husband while my husband remains amicable. Considering the difficult year he has had, I really don't want him to have to deal with that. (8) My sister is treating me like their personal butler suggesting we cook dinner for them at their house (the thank you gift for my parents), or cancel the initial plan to make it work.
AITA For saying we cancel completely and being inflexible?