This is an automated archive.
The original was posted on /r/amitheasshole by /u/Longjumping_Arm8082 on 2023-12-29 05:02:03+00:00.
Hey Reddit, I need your input on a rather unique family situation, and it's got me feeling like the odd one out in a sitcom. Here's the deal:
Background: I'm 35 years old, and my dad recently married a wonderful woman who happens to be a transgender woman (from man to woman). Let me start by saying that I fully support her transition and their marriage. They're happy together, and that's what matters most.
The Quirk: Here's where things get a bit sitcom-ish. My dad and my stepmom now expect all of us adult kids to start calling her "mom." But, I already have a biological mom, and I've always called her "mom." It's been that way for 35 years, and I've got "mom" copyrighted in my heart. For me, nobody can replace my "mom". Plus, I didn't even know my step mom until very recently.
The Dilemma: So, now I'm stuck in this hilarious and somewhat awkward situation where my dad and stepmom want me to start calling her "mom." I can't help but feel like I'm in some bizarre sitcom plotline where there's a "mom" rivalry. I say hilarious but seriously, I feel very weird about it. Some of my siblings do and a few others don't
Over Christmas, she even started crying when I called her by name and we had a big family talk that I felt was very awkward. I tried to be sensitive but I obviously have strong feelings about this...
I love my stepmom and respect her greatly, but the idea of calling her "mom" just makes me cringe a bit. It feels like I'm betraying my biological mom, and it's making family gatherings a comedy of errors with the "mom" mix-up on top of already different dynamics that I'm not quite used to yet but working on...
So, Reddit, AITA for refusing to call my transgender stepmom "mom" when I've already got a "mom"? Is there a way to navigate this situation without it feeling like I'm in a sitcom? Trying hard to figure this one out... I'm not going to lie..., I feel like a very egalitarian person but this has be questioning if I'm in the wrong here.
***edit: a few have mentioned the unclear importance of her being trans. To be clear, this is just new territory for me and I feel like the identity politics are really playing into the pressure of her wanting us to call her mom which adds to her hurt but I still feel like I only want to call my mom mom...