This is an automated archive.
The original was posted on /r/hometheater by /u/ScrupulousArmadillo on 2024-01-13 21:47:46+00:00.
Current 5.1 setup:
- Paradigm CC-190 center
- Paradigm Mini L/R channels
- Paradigm Atom surrounds
- Paradigm DPS-3100 V2 subwoofer ()
- Marantz SR6004 AVR
- Room: 300 square feet area with 9 feet ceiling and two doorless entrances
Main usage:
Location: Canada
In my previous post, I asked about the upgrade with the biggest value for my setup/usage and the best answer was about "upgrade subwoofer".
Unfortunately in Canada, we don't have free shipping and return for subwoofers except SVS. As a result, I have a few options:
- SVS PB-2000 ~2100 CAD all in (right now SOLD OUT) free return
- SVS SB-2000 ~1700 CAD all in free return
- SVS PB-100 ~1500 CAD all in free return
- Paradigm Defiance X12 ~2000 CAD probably free return
- RSL Speedwoofer 12S ~1300 CAD 200 CAD return
- Maybe a few other online US manufacturers that able to ship to Canada
From this list, the RSL subwoofer seems the best value for the money (the 900 CAD difference with PB-2000 is overwhelming). But I have one important question to answer - is it noticeable and meaningful improvement at all? My existing DSP-3100 with 24 Hz frequency (actually there are no real measures on the internet to be sure about his number, therefore could be higher, let's say 28 or 32 Hz) and 200 watts RMS seem shy compared to 16-20 Hz frequency in PB-2000/12S/Defiance X12 with ~500 watts RMS, but I don't even know what to expect and how better the sound would be, and would it be worth 1300 CAD (or at least 1100 CAD if I sold DSP-3100)
I have a few options:
- wait till PB-2000 is in stock, order and try it, then return and decide about RSL 12S or no new subwoofer at all
- order PB-1000 or SB-2000 and try it, then return and decide about RSL 12S or no new subwoofer at all
- Just order RSL 12S and hope for the best
I need advice on these options and, ideally, real-life experience with similar upgrades for the same usage (pay attention - no music listening). Or, maybe, some new option to consider.
P.S. I don't like to use SVS as a "free try" with the initial intention to return it disregarding the results, but I will do it if no better option is available.