This is an automated archive.
The original was posted on /r/relationships by /u/DrWistfulness on 2024-01-04 13:22:04+00:00.
TLDR: MIL is upset and withholding presents for our son because Wife and I won't allow them to put their horses on our property without agreeing to basic politeness.
I have been married to my wife for 10 years, together for 14. During this entire time, her family hasn’t been particularly warm to me, but we’ve been on good terms, never had any issues that I am aware of. Her sisters don’t really talk to me, never have. I realized pretty early on that they didn’t like me, so I gave them their space. My wife 41F, mother-in-law (MIL) 70F and sister-in-law (SIL) 45F all love horses… and I HATE them. But I am accepting of my wife’s hobby and help out a lot because it’s an expensive and time-intensive hobby.
4 years ago my grandmother-in-law passed and left a small inheritance to my MIL. My wife and I have a smallish property and 2 years ago, I was approached by my wife, to allow my MIL to clear land and put a horse enclosure on my property so she and my wife and SIL could keep their horses there. I initially said no. I didn’t think it was a good idea, for many reasons. But every 3 months or so, my wife would ask me again and eventually I caved and said yes but with some conditions: 1) I didn’t want us to have to foot the bill for this after it was installed, they would all three share in the responsibilities and costs 2) I didn’t want this to substantially change my life 3) it was a gift. I didn’t want to be indebted to her family for this. I.e. if we chose to sell the house, we wouldn’t have to pay her back.
My wife and MIL agreed to my terms, but MIL wouldn’t meet with me to discuss the plans or specifics of the project. I let them go and monitored the project. Several times I had to step in and put my foot down that certain aspects needed to be done correctly and not as cheaply as possible. MIL clearly wanted this to be done as quickly and cheaply as possible, but I didn’t want to fix or replace everything in 5 years because it breaks.
In October, we were nearly completed. I had spent the last several months doing backbreaking labor putting in utility lines, clearing land and digging out stumps but the property was not ready. MIL was putting pressure on us to move the horses to avoid paying board, but the shed to store hay wasn’t installed yet and there was debris over the field. The shed base was a point of contention, because they purchased an extremely cheap and flimsy shed that needed to be on a concrete base. MIL and wife didn’t want to put in the time or money to pour a slab, so they were fighting me a bit, but eventually I had to tell them to pour a slab or find another shed because the shed was so flimsy it was a major safety hazard unless properly anchored.
By end of NOV, the slab was poured, the shed installed and the debris cleaned. MIL again wanted to move horses. I wanted to set forth the ground rules and get them to agree to them prior to moving. There were six rules: 1) 30 minutes notice prior to dropping by 2) 24 hour notice for routine vet visits (emergencies don’t require notice) 3) The house is off limits unless invited in (i.e. they can’t come in when they want to use the bathroom) 4) Helmets must be worn when riding 5) Approval and liability forms required for any guests 6) Violation of these rules more than 3 times could result in removal.
This causes a major shitstorm. It was communicated via group text with my, wife, MIL and SIL. MIL agreed to these terms. SIL lost her mind and started to call wife bossy, saying that texting before coming over was completely unreasonable, that she wouldn’t send notice because she’s never had to do that at a boarding place and then said that all because I was an ass. She then started calling me names, accusing me of swindling her mother out of the inheritance. SIL suggests that FIL and MIL should sue me to get the money back.
I was respectful, but hurt. I said that if she didn’t want to agree to the rules, then that’s OK, but no horse on the property. MIL says they will bring my wife’s horse for now since they were already planning to move horses. However, I am not very wary, because litigation has been brought up and Pandora's box can’t be closed. I decide I need to cover myself financially in all this.
There were communications between MIL/SIL/wife and, a couple hours later, I get this text from SIL saying “Sorry for calling you a name.” I was still pretty hurt and responded “Which name? Ass, liar, swindler?” She responded with “ass.” I felt the apology was backhanded and said as much and that I needed some space from her. Since she didn’t agree to the rules, she couldn’t bring her horse.
A couple hours later MIL drops off wife’s horse and leaves. Then an hour after that, MIL sends wife a text saying “we’re here, are you coming out?” I went outside and sure enough, MIL and SIL are unloading their horses in the field. I stormed out of the house and yelled across the yard at them “Why are there 3 horses in my field, MIL?” SIL immediately responded “Get over yourself, dude.” I said “get over myself?! Why don’t you get your horse off my property” She said," No.” I said, “OK, then how about I call the cops, then?” This upset SIL and MIL. MIL started going on about how I should forgive family immediately after blood cools. SIL started saying that I stole the money and why did I take the money. At this point, we were talking on opposite sides of the fence and SIL moved about 60 feet away, mid conversation, so I raised my voice again so she could hear me. Finally, I realized we were at an impasse and I said, “Whatever, keep your horses here, I don’t give a shit” and walked back into the house. They decided to take their horses and leave.
After that, I decided we needed a boarding agreement where the rules and liabilities are clearly defined. We drafted a very standard boarding agreement and sent it to MIL and SIL. MIL, agreed. When SIL returned the document there was a slew of untracked changes, some of which would cause wife and I to be liable for unreasonable things like her horse getting sick or injured. Potentially putting us on the hook for thousands. SIL is a paralegal for an insurance company, so she knew exactly what she was doing. I confirmed with SIL via email all her changes to the document, but was respectful to her. We said there was no way we could accept this agreement as it would void our insurance policy. It seemed like we were at an impasse again. We say that MIL is allowed to bring her horse at any time. SIL needs to agree to the original terms. SIL declines. MIL doesn’t bring her horse.
Then father-in-law gets involved. FIL starts texting wife trying to resolve the situation. Saying MIL doesn’t trust me anymore (not sure why). MIL starts sending texts saying the barn value needed to go into the boarding agreement so “if she leaves, the barn goes too.” I think… “um.. no.”
He then asks to have a sit down with myself and wife as an “information gathering session.” We agree and he’s very respectful and calm and just says that he is planning to pay MIL back the money she put into the property and make her whole as well as give SIL the same amount. He’s trying to smooth things over. Says MIL and SIL were “joking” about the suits and not being a gift. I am amazed that this is happening, but hey… it’s his money. I’d prefer to be out of all this, but I also don’t want to get sued for any of it. We depart on good terms, with us saying we will send over an updated boarding agreement. We leave on good, smiling terms.
The next day, I send FIL a text and say that we need to sign a gift affidavit saying the horse enclosure and barn are a gift (as originally promised) before drafting new boarding agreements. He agrees and says that the funds will be transferred to make MIL whole by the end of the week. We agree to meet the following week to sign the forms at a notary. When we meet, MIL is in the car and FIL is inside. FIL is not happy or friendly, but says hi. MIL enters and doesn’t say a word. I figure “I guess everyone is mad now.” So we don’t say much, sign the paperwork and as we exit, MIL very loudly says “Oh now I am pissed.” Wife and I are like WTF? We say “thank you” as they are walking away and leave. It was a very tense situation overall.
Several days go by, Christmas goes by. We send over our normal presents to MIL and wife’s family. She thanks us for the gifts and tells us that she’s mad because I didn’t apologize to her for yelling and we both didn’t thank them (even though we did say thank you as we left).
Then there are a bunch of texts between wife and MIL where MIL is trying to convince wife of a different series of events. One where SIL and MIL haven’t done anything wrong. One where I was planning to do this all along and steal her money. And where I am a crazy person that yelled at MIL for no reason. Wife isn’t buying it and starts getting angry. Tells MIL to review all the texts and emails because they are very eye-opening.
At this point, we decide SIL is out. The Invitation to put her horse on our property is rescinded. Wife and I aren’t going to play this game every time SIL gets upset, behaves poorly and then MIL jumps in to defend her blindly. MIL is still permitted to put her horse here. MIL starts sending texts about how ungrateful we are pointing out all the times she's be generous in the past and how we should let SIL put her horse here.
The next day, we get a text from ...
Content cut off. Read original on https://www.reddit.com/r/relationships/comments/18yd21x/wife_41f_and_i_42m_agreed_to_allow_mil_70f_and/