This is an automated archive.
The original was posted on /r/relationships by /u/genigenes on 2023-12-30 21:21:28+00:00.
Thank you for your willingness to help!
I (29 M) have been for 7 years in a relationship with Amanda (29 F). We are from different parts of Peru but met studying abroad almost 10 years ago. When we met we were best friends for 2-3 years given she was dating someone by then. Afterward, she broke up to once again study abroad in another country (while I was in Peru), but after me visiting her twice, we actually started a relationship long distance for 1.5 years before we lived in the same city in Peru. I think the relationship was extremely good in the first 2 years and then was still very good for the next years, but maybe a little less romantic (maybe because we worked/studied very hard or because we got used to it).
Recently, we both moved to the USA, where we studied different programs (MBA & Master’s) at the same university. I think we both overly focused on our social experience in these programs and ended up living our own individual lives there, which grew us apart. Both of us had our faults and our complaints. I complained a lot about her overly partying and drinking with friends (she is very social and excited, so always wants to be the last to leave and at some point was partying almost every day), about having “too deep” relationships with man friends, and about overly prioritizing her friends vs. me. She complained about me not giving her enough attention, not being romantic anymore, and overly pressuring her to go find a job (I never actually said anything that hurt her, but I tried to help her a lot and remind her of to-dos and this would trigger her) or also not prioritizing our relationship. It was a moment that we both wanted to take advantage of the limited time we had in our programs, but it ended up taking a toll on our relationship. At the end of the year, we were arguing almost every day, and when walking on the streets, we barely could talk due to resentment of each others’ complaints, so we barely were able to have fun together.
In the end, her program lasted for one year while mine lasts for 2 years (6 months to go), and, now in the second year, she ended up only finding a job on the other coast, so we are doing a long-distance relationship as I finish my studies. This is not helping us restore our relationship as we ended the in-person time in not the best way.
More recently, I met a woman at my school who I became friends with, and over the past 3 months, I think I slightly “fell in love” with her a little bit. We started as just friends, but I think we unwittingly developed feelings for each other. When she started feeling something, I think there was a day that she tried to see if I would cheat, but I didn’t engage in her invites (like having wine with her, etc). I was loyal to my partner the whole time but at the same time I liked hanging out with her as a friend so kept meeting her in group activities or even in some 1-on-1 chats as friends. I never cheated but I will be frank in saying that in some heated moments, I was slightly flirtier than I should’ve been (nothing big though, just maybe overly texting or longer goodbye hugs, etc) – I would say this other woman also fell for me (at least physically). However, now I think I reach a point where I need to respectful and reassess how I act, either cut this new woman out of my mind/diminish her in my life or end my relationship. I am not sure whether this woman has any long-term interest in me or if we would work out together anyway, so I think my decision on whether to stay with my current girlfriend should be more related to our relationship (forgetting about the existence of this new woman, even though frankly I’m infatuated right now and can even see us as a good match for a relationship – though I recognize I’m only seeing the positives at this point).
Looking at my current relationship, I think the positives is that my partner is by nature happy, lighthearted, and a pleasurable companion; can bond with many people; is very smart, pretty/hot, and trustworthy; has in general similar hobbies to mine; and helps me on my decisions and on solving my own life. All of that, especially when we are not in our worst case (now). I think on the other side, I think she drinks/parties more than what I feel comfortable with and is not willing to make some adjustments to please me (like drinking a little less or not being the last one to leave); also some times I feel that she overly values friendships in detriment to romantic relationships (e.g. she always wants to do stuff with other people while I also value having only us-time). Lastly, I think there are some other arguments that, unfortunately, are a little futile and maybe not nice that come to my head indirectly – but I will share them here in the spirit of transparency. One of the things I valued in my partner is that I learned a lot from her from her strong intuition in decision-making and her strong emotional intelligence. Right now, I feel like I’d love to date someone that is part of the American culture and that works in my field, so I can learn more from that person (and from their friends) as sometimes I get bored talking to my partner friends for instance and I get a little lost in the US culture. Additionally, I unfortunately am the type of person that always thinks stuff could be better like, even though my GF is attractive, maybe I could still find one even more attractive (or that will teach me more or will be more home-centered, etc). Finally, sometimes I also feel about the thrill of being single and exploring other girls and having more single adventures in life. As a summary, I’m at a bad moment in the relationship but still recognize great quality on my GF and potential for our relationship (even though right now is poor), while also recognizing some of our limitations and things that I unconsciously think (being 100% transparent and trying to read myself deeply after a lot of self-reflection). I want to stay at least 3 years in the US working and my GF wants to come back sooner; so we would also have to have a compromise on a shared future for it to work (most likely her staying in the US given this is my only opportunity in life to do so because of visa issues and given she also already has a job here)
As a last parenthesis, this new girl I met also has her own qualities. I feel she is a little bit more ambitious, classy, and tries to push me out of my comfort zone more (which I like). She is equally smart and attractive (maybe even slightly less). I also like that she is able to teach me a lot about her own heritage culture, the US culture (she is mixed), and her industry of work, which I like talking about and is closer to my field. On the other hand, she feels like she doesn’t seem too invested in helping me in my own decisions when I needed her help and the fact that she “pushed” a bit for us to do something while I’m in a relationship could be a bad sign, even though she did not insist afterward and it was somewhat indirect. In the scenario I’m single I see her as a potential dating partner given I like her but don’t want to make a decision considering this, especially given I don’t even know if she is interested or if we would work out. But, in the end, this girl also showed me that I need an urgent fix to my relationship problems and I should stop postponing solving/getting rid of them – being frank once again, I feel a slight time pressure in the sense that if I think I should break up, I should do soon given I could still meet people in the last months of school. Also, on the other side, pressure for engagement and marriage are starting to arise and I need to make my mind around it – I’m a very rational/cautious/comprehensive decision maker so committing to a marriage is something that is very hard to me (which I think will always be independently of the partner I am with).
Well, you can also look at my post story to see previous dilemmas I had on this same relationship, but remember that they will be somewhat negatively biased, which is not representative of it – I think we did have a very nice time together so far and I believe my girlfriend is a great person. In short, where I need help reflecting is around the question of whether (1) I should stay with my current girlfriend and try to work on the relationship further (we had many issues in the past, but this is the first time I look at it from the perspective of breaking up or not instead of just trying to fix the issue) or (2) I should break up?
Thank you for listening to everything and I appreciate your most direct and true opinions, even if you are not sure about it.
TL;DR: In (M29) a 7-year relationship with GF (F29), with whom I share a history of connection and compatibility. Recently, after moving to the USA for studies and experiencing social expansions, our relationship has faced challenges like less quality time together, differing lifestyles, and arguments. Concurrently, I've developed feelings for a new woman, causing me to reevaluate my current relationship. I'm torn between working on my existing relationship or considering a breakup to explore new possibilities and personal desires