Digital Fiefdom (aka walled-garden) Required
This community collects stories, cases and situations where people are forced into a walled-garden to carry out a public transaction or essential task of some kind. As governments impose a digital transformation policy with no analog refuge, people are forced into becoming serfs in a technofeudal system that is subservient to lords (Microsoft, Cloudflare, Google, etc).
Well-known walled gardens include (but are not limited to):
- Cloudflare
- Microsoft LinkedIn
- Microsoft Github¹
- Paypal
- Amazon
- iOS
(note I do not say X or Meta above because I do not recognize or promote obnoxious and detrimental trademarks)
¹It’s somewhat unlikely that a gov would impose Github, but it is listed as an example because some govs do have git services. E.g. the EU has a public-facing self-hosted git instance.
Somewhat related communities:
view the rest of the comments
You confuse bandwidth and resources. Bots are often the most impactful clients of any site, because serving an image costs virtually nothing. Generating a dynamic page is WAY more resource intensive.
Bandwidth is a resource. Citations needed for claims to the contrary.
Nonsense. Text compresses extremely well. Images and media do not in the slightest approach the leanness of text.
Try using the web through a 2400 baud modem. Or try using a mobile connection with a small monthly quota of like 3gb and no other access. You will disable images your browser settings in no time.
Bots and humans both trigger dynamic processing, but bots and humans of text-based clients to a lesser extent because the bandwidth-heavy media is usually not fetched as a consequence and JavaScript is not typically fetched and executed in the first place.
I'm guessing you've never run infra for a popular site before.
Yes bandwidth is a resource, but unless you're hosting Flickr or haven't optimized your images, it's not the most in demand resource. It's also one of the cheapest parts, compared to paying for the ram / CPU / multiple machines required to support a large site.
I've debugged hundreds of customers who suddenly had their site fall over. Not a single one was due to their bandwidth being saturated, it's almost always bots hitting some poorly optimized code.
Trying to spin images as the primary resource consumer of running websites, just isn't true.
This guy infras.