Fediverse

Yeah, there will be instances that people run that have bigoted and harassful content and the like, and there are people who don't want to see any of that and want to be on an instance that blocks that, that's fine. But I don't see a good reason why any two unproblematic instances should be disconnected.

I see your point about some instances wanting to cultivate their own ecosystem and not blend in to one monotony. But to keep things disconnected is like giving a lung transplant to someone with a cough. It's an extreme solution to the problem that could be solved in other ways with fewer negative consequences.

That's why local exists if you just want to view content from your home server. That's why communities exist on lemmy. And there are easily other solutions that could be created. You could have different algorithms for filtering content. To block content from other instances for this issue is overkill. And it's unfair to users. Will users be warned before joining an instance that they are not being provided a window into the fediverse but instead a segregated platform?

People have grown accustomed to having full and convenient access to everything. That's why everyone joined the big platforms in the first place. You don't want 12 different accounts to interact with your friends on various platforms. You want to keep it simple and powerful. And it's confusing and annoying for new people when they see content linked somewhere else but they can't find it from their own instance. I ran into this many times when I was new to the fediverse.

Of course every instance manager has a right to run theirs the way they see fit, if they really want to do it differently or not federate at all that is their right. But I think with a lot of instance managers it is not intentional. Managing their instance is maybe not the most important thing in their life, more of a hobby. So just like not all instances on lemmy.ml's list always update to the latest version right away, they may not pay attention to the minutia of other small instances out there. And clearly they are not concerned with the problems you mentioned, otherwise they would not federate with lemmy.ml. So I think the solution is to give tools to make it easier for them to federate with lots of other servers, maybe automatically, for those who want it.