I'm no astrophysicist, but if it's in the Kuiper belt doesn't that disqualify it for one of the criteria of being a planet, since it hasn't cleared its neighborhood?
this post was submitted on 03 Sep 2023
16 points (100.0% liked)
Space
81 readers
2 users here now
Cover author: Michał Kałużny http://astrofotografia.pl/
founded 2 years ago
The Kuiper belt is way too big to really be considered a "neighborhood". We're talking about an unfathomably huge area full of many orders of magnitude more objects than we have so far been able to identify.
A planet-like body could easily be clearing its orbit out there without us being able to definitely detect the absence of material in that orbital area.
Moreover, various "Planet Nine" theories I have seen estimate this theoretical object's size as 1.5-5x the size of the earth. If an object that big isn't qualifying as a planet by definition, it's the definition that's wrong.
Excited to see if they can finally find this planet