this post was submitted on 27 Sep 2023
43 points (95.7% liked)
Woodworking
6611 readers
26 users here now
A handmade home for woodworkers and admirers of woodworkers. Our community icon is submitted by @[email protected] whose father was inspired to start woodworking by Norm and the New Yankee Workshop.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Hard tooth saws actually serve a different purpose than traditional soft tooth saws, even though they do work well for traditional tasks.
With the greater adoption of synthetic materials (melamine, plywood, etc) craftsman needed tools with greater edge retention as these new materials were brutal on the edge. Thus the disposable hard tooth saw was born. It was sharp, it stayed sharp and you just toss it when it gets dull.
I work with only normal lumber and mostly soft wood and I prefer traditional saws. With a saw I can sharpen I can sharpen it as much as I want and maintain peak performance at all times. With disposables I find that you tend to keep using them until they are kind of unbearable.
When I get a soft tooth saw I find that it usually needs to be reprofiled but after that it's a piece of cake to sharpen again.
Also for hard teeth saws you can sort of sharpen them, or at least increase their lifespan a little. You can place the saw flat on a sharpening stone and sharpen the outside of the teeth. You can't do this for long however as the saw's set is ground away.
Additionally disposables can be good if you want to use a saw that requires a lot of skill to sharpen (like a Japanese dozuki saw).
If you decide to get a soft tooth saw I recommend buying used and checking out plenty of discount shops. These were pumped out by the millions and there are still out there. Since most saws use the same steel you don't need to worry about getting a "defective" one since any will work fine. The only thing you may need to do, other than sharpening, is shape the handle. A lot of handles were mass produced on a router and are super thick, chunky and uncomfortable. Carving them down with your knife will improve it dramatically.
Aside from that it's just personal preference and I don't look down on anyone that prefers hard tooth saws and it doesn't make you a "lesser" wood worker (you should still learn to sharpen a saw so you can try a traditional saw)
Also for hand planes a #5 vs #4 are mostly down to preference, some people like slightly longer and heavier like the #5 and vice versa.
Same with saws I recommend a used handplane because tons of them exist and they should be cheap.
Make sure to get a usable hand plane, a good one should have
Cast iron frog and body
Comfortable tote (rear handle) and knob (front handle)
A Mostly flat sole, a lot of cheap planes are really badly warped and take forever to flatten, a mostly flat one will save you a ton of time.
No deep rust on the blade. Surface rust is fine but deep pitting on the flat side of the iron will prevent you from sharpening it properly
No cracks in the sole and body
Tight mouth (not super necessary if the frog is adjustable)
No major chips on the blade or god forbid a bevel on the flat side because someone's too lazy to properly sharpen it.
Some premium features to look for too
Handles made from premium or exotic wood (many Stanley's used rosewood)
Thick machined chip breaker and iron
many brass or bronze parts, even the body on extremely premium examples
Frog set screw, not a super premium feature and medium range planes should have it. The lack of one isn't a deal breaker though
Lateral adjustment levers made with multiple parts (cheap planes will have one stamped)
For restoring and tuning your plane I would highly recommend Rex Krueger's videos.