Any plant can grow with "artificial" light. It's just a matter of generating the correct light spectrum for a plant. There's nothing special about the light coming from the sun.
this post was submitted on 18 Apr 2024
83 points (91.9% liked)
Today I Learned (TIL)
7331 readers
4 users here now
You learn something new every day; what did you learn today?
/c/til is a community for any true knowledge that you would like to share, regardless of topic or of source.
Share your knowledge and experience!
Rules
- Information must be true
- Follow site rules
- No, you don't have to have literally learned the fact today
- Posts must be about something you learned
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
Well, there is one thing special about the light from the Sun... there's a shit ton of it.
Also, it's free.
Well sunlight is full spectrum colour plus ultraviolet and infrared. I'm sure there are benefits to the plant we can't easily measure, since they evolved with full specteum. We found a LED grow bulb with a yellow LED besides RED and BLUE, the plants grow like crazy
That's going to be less efficient per watt though, plant's are green because they don't use the green light, hence red+blue grow lights.
Not all plants reflect the same range of wavelengths though, and different plants will use different wavelengths to grow. This is basically an exercise in finding which wavelengths we can drop without significantly slowing growth for each plant.
This articles says plants only absorb 90% of green photons even though green has moat energy, as a way to mitigate over and under lighting in the chemical process. https://www.quantamagazine.org/why-are-plants-green-to-reduce-the-noise-in-photosynthesis-20200730/
That article just throws out a number. I found a couple papers that give green light absorption numbers between 50% (for lettuce) and 90% (for broadleaf evergreens). Sadly they are paywalled.
The paper that article links talks about pairs of absorption peaks targeting steep portions of the available light spectrum, as a method of reducing power noise in changing conditions. The reason for avoiding green light here would be because the spectrum is too flat around green: there are no pits to help stabilize incoming power. Despite blue light having nearly identical intensity, green plants strongly absorb blue light, supposedly because there's a steep drop off in intensity moving into purple and ultraviolet light. I don't think this explains the decently strong red light absorption though, as the terrestrial spectrum is still rather flat there.
I'd argue this is more a holdover from competition with simpler purple Haloarchaea in ancient oceans, the Purple Earth Hypothesis . Perhaps this avoidance of the otherwise strong green light is what allowed green plants to develop complex structures and those complex structures need much smoother power input, precluding the development of green light photosynthesis. Also possible is that developing new photosynthetic pathways is just too difficult, and green plants are too specialized to try.
Some of those specializations may be the use of green light to direct non-photisynthetic processes, detailed in this paper, which is also more directly relevant to the original point. Some green light increases yields significantly, despite maybe not promoting photosynthesis as efficiently per watt as red & blue light.
Yes, seems highly complex and we may not fully understand it all yet.
Most plants do. That's why they're green - they reflect the photons from the mid range, and absorb the ones from the extremes (red and blue/violet) to actually work their shit. Like this:
Picture from Wikipedia.
(I wonder how efficient this would be to power exclusively with solar light. How many layers of plants could we grow, where we usually grow only one?)
Neat! I knew that but the pic is worth 1,000 words.
Weed can grow with artificial sunlight too, people have know this for years now!
Yeah I'm sitting here wondering what all the fuss is about, that's how I've grown weed for decades lmao.
Plants are sluts for light, they don't care where it comes from as long as it comes on them.
ooo I'm eating lettuce from my lil' hydroponics system right now! It uses a small pump to circulate nutrients and that gamer-powered light energy.
It's the only way I can keep plants alive... give them back to nature...
Pretty sure plants need a rest period as well
I dont know about need, but a lot of weed farmers feel that plants do better with a rest/dark period. I haven't noticed a difference but give them a rest period anyway as its "natural"
I tried growing a plant in a closet once. The instructions I was given were to leave the light on 24/7 until it was as big as I wanted, then to switch to a 12 on/ 12 off cycle to get it to bud.
I didn’t try very hard on it and ended up with a quarter of mid weed after like 6 months
Is that alot?
7g, so not really
Got the wife an aerogarden for Christmas. We’ve been growing a ton of herbs indoors with just the led lights for months. Wait til you find out you don’t even need soil to grow stuff