Community Requests - Lemmy.ca

140 readers

7 users here now

Please post here if you wish to request moderation of an unmoderated community. Include details of why you are applying to take over the community.

Communities will be considered unmoderated if the community moderators have had no activity within the community for a month. All requests will be vetted and reviewed by the Lemmy.ca Admin Team, who will give the community moderators 5 days to appeal the request.

founded 2 years ago

MODERATORS

124

Announcing the Launch of CommunityRequests (self.communityrequests)

submitted 2 years ago* (last edited 2 years ago) by SourCreamAndGarlic to c/communityrequests

34 comments fedilink hide all child comments

Howdy folks,

We're launching c/CommunityRequests to combat a growing issue on Lemmy.ca in general, which is unmoderated communities. What this will do is allow you to apply to take over an unmoderated community by posting in c/CommunityRequests a request to take the community over. Ultimately we decided to steal the system used on Reddit, but with some modifications to make it a bit more fair to users submitting requests.

Our initial guidelines are as follows:

A community will be considered unmoderated if the moderators have not interacted with the community for over a month.
Users may request communities where no moderators are interacting with the community.
Moderators within the community may ask to have the top mod replaced if the top mod is inactive, but other moderators are still active.
In both cases, moderators have 5 days to appeal the request. If no appeal is received within the time-frame, the request will be granted by the Admin Team to the requestor.
Requests made in bad faith will be rejected. For example, requesting a community you have been permanently banned from for justified reasons, or requesting a community in order to completely change the purpose of it for the worse.

These guidelines may be adjusted a bit as time goes on. This is a new system and we're going to need to try things for a bit to see if they work or not.

In any event, feel free to start using the community immediately. Please give us feedback on your thoughts and ideas!

Cheers, Ms. SourCreamAndGarlic

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[–] Zamboniman 34 points 2 years ago (10 children)

I think the one month with no moderator activity should only be applicable if there is other user activity in the community during that month. For small, specific, and (so far) very quiet communities I think a month of no moderator activity if there's no activity at all yet doesn't make much sense.

[–] SourCreamAndGarlic 23 points 2 years ago* (last edited 2 years ago) (8 children)

In some cases, communities are set to be moderator-only, which is to say that only moderators are allowed to post in them. As well, we want to avoid community squatting by power moderators (think 20+ communities with no interactions) who create communities so they can keep controlling them later on when people suddenly start using them. This was the bane of Reddit's existence, and something we don't want to have propagate over to Lemmy.ca under any circumstances.

Regardless, this is why we have the 5 day window for moderators to respond to let us know what's going on, so we can get that context. Ultimately we don't want to reassign a community unless it's obvious that the user moderating it has no interest in actively moderating, or is holding onto it in bad faith.

Thanks for contributing. These are perspectives we want to keep in mind.

[–] otter 14 points 2 years ago (5 children)

My only suggestion would be to maybe make the window a little longer. While I use Lemmy a lot (and I used Reddit a lot too), I can see 5 days being too little for some people who are busy with work to write up a proper explanation.

At the same time, I guess there is a question about how well moderated a community is if no one checks in for 5 days. Could you have it so that the request needs to be acknowledged within a week, but a proper explanation has a longer window?

[–] TruckBC 6 points 2 years ago (1 children)

I guess there is a question about how well moderated a community is if no one checks in for 5 days.

This is exactly where the 5 days comes from.

The issue we're facing is there are some active communities that are getting reports where the current moderators are not active, not dealing with reports, and not responding to communication from admins.

While it's workable on a small scale, as admins we shouldn't be defacto relief moderators, and really shouldn't be enforcing any community specific rules.